Heat pumps: a waste of money or a way to slash bills?

Some households show off sharply lower heating bills after installing a heat pump. Others complain that it costs more than burning gas. How can the same technology produce opposite results? The answer depends on how efficiently the machine moves heat and how much the household pays for electricity. Electricity has long been more expensive than gas in Britain, so saving energy does not automatically mean saving money. But a changing electricity-to-gas price ratio, combined with time-of-use tariffs, can transform the calculation. Mix together old prices, different homes and different energy contracts, and the debate quickly becomes a collection of incompatible claims. Understanding the bill starts with understanding the machine.

Heat pumps have been part of everyday life for decades. Fridges and freezers move heat from inside the cabinet to the surrounding room, keeping food cold. The warmth around their heat-dissipating surfaces is the heat being released. Air conditioners do the same thing, moving heat from indoors to outdoors. A reversible air conditioner can switch modes and bring outdoor heat inside during winter, operating as an air-to-air heat pump. Many Hong Kong households have already used heat pumps for heating without calling them that. The air-to-water systems commonly connected to British radiators and underfloor heating warm water, which then carries heat around the home. Both use the same basic principle.

The key is a refrigerant circulating through sealed pipework. In the outdoor heat exchanger, the refrigerant is colder than the surrounding air, so it absorbs heat and evaporates. A compressor raises the pressure and temperature of the vapour. The refrigerant then transfers heat to the heating water and condenses into a liquid. Passing through an expansion valve lowers its pressure and temperature, ready for another round of heat collection. Even when the outdoor temperature is 0 degrees Celsius, a colder refrigerant can still absorb heat. Heat output divided by electricity consumption is the coefficient of performance, or COP. A COP of 4 means that 1 kilowatt-hour of electricity supplies 4 kilowatt-hours of heat.

Efficiency changes with operating conditions. Colder outdoor air and hotter heating water generally mean a larger temperature gap for the machine to overcome and greater electricity consumption. Frost also requires energy for defrosting. Larger radiators can deliver the required heat at a lower water temperature, while underfloor heating is well suited to low-temperature operation. Poor system design, unnecessarily high water temperatures and heavy reliance on electric resistance backup heaters can all increase consumption. Annual running costs should therefore be assessed using measured performance across the year, including space heating, hot water and associated electricity use. The seasonal performance factor, or SPF, is more useful for this purpose than an impressive COP recorded on a mild afternoon.

The cost comparison is straightforward. Divide the electricity price by the heat pump’s efficiency to find the electricity cost per unit of heat. Divide the gas price by the boiler’s efficiency to find the gas cost per unit of heat. For October to December 2026, average price-cap unit rates for direct debit customers in Great Britain are 26.32 pence per kilowatt-hour for electricity and 7.97 pence for gas. Assuming a gas boiler is 90 per cent efficient, each kilowatt-hour of heat costs about 8.86 pence. A heat pump with an annual performance factor of 3.5 delivers it for about 7.52 pence, making the energy consumption cost roughly 15 per cent lower.

A report published by Ecotricity founder Dale Vince in January 2026 assumed that electricity cost 3.867 times as much as gas, with a heat pump performance factor of 2.8 and a boiler efficiency of 90 per cent. It calculated that the heat pump would cost around 24 per cent more to run. That result depends on those particular price and efficiency assumptions. The report’s warnings about installation quality and cost deserve attention. But extending that calculation into a general claim that heat pumps cannot save money overlooks changing prices and the choice of electricity contracts. To judge whether the conclusion still holds, we need to ask why British electricity once cost more than 4 times as much as gas, and how that ratio is changing.

Britain’s long-standing electricity price of more than 4 times the gas price was an unreasonable policy outcome from the outset. Electricity bills have carried more of the cost of renewable energy and decarbonisation policies, alongside social policy costs such as the Warm Home Discount. Burning gas to generate electricity attracts a carbon price. Burning it directly in a household boiler does not face an equivalent charge. This arrangement places more transition costs on electricity and gives direct gas heating a price advantage. The government encourages households to adopt low-carbon heating while weakening the financial incentive through their bills. An unreasonable price structure has therefore cancelled out part of the benefit of heat pumps’ energy efficiency.

That ratio is now narrowing. The government has moved some policy costs off energy bills, and electricity is currently temporarily exempt from VAT. Meanwhile, gas prices have recently risen faster than electricity prices, also reducing the ratio. Average official unit rates for October to December 2026 are 26.32 pence for electricity and 7.97 pence for gas, a ratio of about 3.3. Existing forecasts suggest it could fall further to around 3.1 in January 2027. Overall energy bills can still rise while heat pumps become cheaper to run relative to gas boilers. Continuing to use an old ratio close to 4, or higher, overstates the relative running costs of heat pumps under today’s prices and those forecasts.

Some households with both an electric vehicle and a heat pump use Intelligent Octopus Go, or IOG, with cheap electricity at around 7 pence per kilowatt-hour. Its overnight discount applies to the whole home from 11.30 pm to 5.30 am, including the heat pump. At 7 pence per kilowatt-hour and an operating COP of 3, the electricity cost is only about 2.3 pence per kilowatt-hour of heat. Households with a home battery can also charge it during the cheap period and use the stored electricity to power the heat pump later in the day. Battery capacity, power output and charging and discharging losses determine how long that benefit can last.

Heat pump households without an electric vehicle can consider time-of-use tariffs such as Cosy. Cosy offers 8 cheap hours each day, split between 4 am and 7 am, 1 pm and 4 pm, and 10 pm and midnight. These distributed periods make heating easier to schedule than a single overnight window. With suitable insulation, modest preheating and hot water storage, some households can shift most heat pump electricity consumption into the cheaper periods and reduce operation during the expensive early evening. Calculations based solely on standard electricity rates miss the savings available through tariff choice and storage. They also fail to explain why some households achieve substantial reductions in their bills.

Why do some households save much more than others? Equipment efficiency, tariff choice, the previous heating system and the way the heat pump is scheduled all matter. Bill comparisons also need to account for the weather, indoor temperatures and heating hours. Keeping a home warmer for longer can use up some of the savings. The decision to install should include the cost after grants, maintenance and whether the existing boiler already needs replacing. Britain needs prices that reward efficient equipment, alongside good system design and clear quotations. When considering a heat pump, what matters most to you: the installation cost, the annual bills or keeping the whole home warm for longer? Share your thoughts in the comments.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top